Students in Italy are imitating their French and Spanish counterparts, but with their own brand of guerrilla posturing straight out of some third-rate action flick.
I don’t want to follow Pasolini’s example. He argued, not without good reason, that between the young protesters and the riot police, he preferred the latter, because they were working-class sons of the people, whereas the former were pampered sons of wealthy fathers.
He made this observation in the wake of Valle Giulia (1 March 1968), when the students, united but with the neofascists making up almost the entire front line, defeated the police forces in the streets. In the collective imagination of the protesters of that era, the event became an epoch-making symbol, even a harbinger of a revolution that was later aborted or betrayed.
Pasolini was not entirely wrong, but what was happening at the time was the product of youthful vitality, against a backdrop of demographic expansion, urbanisation and the emergence of a new generation of social elites. A kind of joyous, titanic striving to conquer the heavens took shape.
And even if the sons of wealthy fathers joined in playing at revolution, they did not necessarily do so on a whim. They were not the only ones involved, and for some of them it meant changing their entire lives, forever.
Then came disillusionment. The 1977 movement was already something quite different. It was characterised by bitterness, frustration, nihilism and a form of armed struggle that was more anarchic than programmatic.
It is important to grasp these differences, because some events have a certain radiance about them, while others are dark.
And then there are the farces. Today, we are in the midst of a full-blown farce.
The precedents I have mentioned
nevertheless belonged to periods of social tension and widespread social engagement. Although anger and a cognitive disorder led certain self-proclaimed avant-gardes to devise delusional schemes that ended in bloody disaster, there was still some connection to reality. Today, all meaning is exhausted by selfies and self-representations staged at events that serve no purpose beyond themselves.
The adolescent bout of acne that accompanies hysterical attempts at self-assertion is a recurring phenomenon, and one that is perfectly understandable. When it attaches itself to a cause, it can take on a different meaning. But when it is nothing more than pure theatre, a form of narcissism disconnected from anything whatsoever, apart from far-fetched and laughable demands, everything changes.
Adriano Romualdi tried in vain to persuade his comrades not to take part in Valle Giulia, arguing—and rightly so—that they would end up playing into the hands of the Communists and subversives regardless. Others, including his close friend Mario Merlino, believed it was worth getting involved and contesting the ground held by their opponents. Events proved Romualdi right, but I would have acted like Merlino, because even missed victories and political defeats can be turned to advantage if they lead to personal growth and produce collateral gains, perhaps ones that were never anticipated.
I doubt that today’s student protesters have given the matter even a moment’s thought. They want to immortalise themselves in social media “stories” while making a pointless racket. They are not fighting for national independence, class struggle or generational revolt. They are doing it for demagogic nonsense: school costs, rearmament and other such idiocies.
In effect, they are foolish pawns
in the manoeuvres of the Campo Largo, the broad centre-left coalition, as well as of foreign powers seeking to weaken and subjugate European nations, from both outside and within.
But perhaps it is asking too much to expect these people to understand how they are being manipulated and despised by the very same people pulling their strings.
Strip away the exhibitionism and the adrenaline rush, and I doubt there is anything else to be found in these noisy spectacles.
Having started with Pasolini, we can only end by quoting Marx: “History repeats itself, first as tragedy, second as farce.”
Preserve the sharper original imageryClarify ambiguous political references

